Three weeks later, Nelly discovers that Cathy has been visiting Wuthering Heights most evenings by bribing a groom. Narrator in Wluthering Heights GIDEON SHUNAMI T HE POINT OF VIEW in Wuthering Heights results from a com-bination of two speakers who outline the events of the plot within the framework of a story within a story. The novel has been popular in opera and theatre, including operas written by Bernard Herrmann, Carlisle Floyd, and Frédéric Chaslin (most cover only the first half of the book) and a musical by Bernard J. Taylor. While it was perhaps grander than Wuthering Heights, the hall had grotesque embellishments of griffins and misshapen nude males similar to those described by Lockwood in Chapter 1 of the novel. The earliest known film adaptation of Wuthering Heights was filmed in England in 1920 and was directed by A. V. Bramble. Lockwood is an English gentleman who arrives on the Yorkshire moors for a retreat from city life. Wuthering Heights is the name of the Yorkshire estate on which much of the novel's action takes place. Emily Brontë's approach to the novel form was influenced, in addition to Scott, especially by the Gothic novel, and, in what is usually considered the first gothic novel, The Castle of Otranto (1764) Horace Walpole's declared aim was to combine elements of the medieval romance, which he deemed too fanciful, and the modern novel, which he considered to be too confined to strict realism.[38]. All readers know more than any one narrator, and therefore are empowered as they read. It is very puzzling and very interesting, and if we had space we would willingly devote a little more time to the analysis of this remarkable story, but we must leave it to our readers to decide what sort of book it is. The 1992 film Emily Brontë's Wuthering Heights starring Ralph Fiennes and Juliette Binoche is notable for including the oft-omitted second generation story of the children of Cathy, Hindley and Heathcliff. Nelly Dean examines the events retrospectively and attempts to report them as an objective eyewitness to Lockwood. That night Lockwood has a nightmare in which he breaks a window to get some air, and a child grabs his hand. The frame story is that of Lockwood, who informs us of his meeting with the strange and mysterious "family" living in almost total isolation in the stony uncultivated land of northern England. Catherine Earnshaw born (summer); Isabella Linton born (late 1765), Heathcliff brought to Wuthering Heights by Mr Earnshaw (late summer), Hindley sent off to university by his father, Hindley marries Frances; Mr Earnshaw dies and Hindley comes back (October); Heathcliff and Catherine visit Thrushcross Grange for the first time; Catherine remains behind (November), and then returns to Wuthering Heights (Christmas Eve), Heathcliff runs away from Wuthering Heights; Mr and Mrs Linton both die, Catherine has married Edgar (March); Heathcliff comes back (September), Heathcliff marries Isabella (February); Catherine dies and Cathy born (20 March); Hindley dies; Linton Heathcliff born (September), Isabella dies; Cathy visits Wuthering Heights and meets Hareton; Linton brought to Thrushcross Grange and then taken to Wuthering Heights, Cathy meets Heathcliff and sees Linton again (20 March), Cathy and Linton are married (August); Edgar dies (August); Linton dies (September); Mr Lockwood goes to Thrushcross Grange and visits Wuthering Heights, beginning his narrative, Mr Lockwood goes back to London (January); Heathcliff dies (April); Mr Lockwood comes back to Thrushcross Grange (September), This page was last edited on 11 December 2020, at 13:12. "[15], Tait's Edinburgh Magazine wrote "This novel contains undoubtedly powerful writing, and yet it seems to be thrown away. The novel has inspired many adaptations, including film, radio and television dramatisations; a musical; a ballet; operas; and a hit song. Nelly, thus, belongs to Wuthering Heights and Thrushcross Grange in a way that the outsider Lockwood (or Heathcliff either) never does. The novel was first published together with Anne Brontë's Agnes Grey in a three-volume format: Wuthering Heights occupied the first two volumes, while Agnes Grey made up the third. Nelly Dean serves as the chief narrator of Wuthering Heights. Her narrative style is very different from Lockwood’s; plain and colloquial … Mizumura Minae's A True Novel (Honkaku shosetsu) (2002) is inspired by Wuthering Heights and might be called an adaptation of the story in a post-World War II Japanese setting.[64]. We have been taken and carried through a new region, a melancholy waste, with here and there patches of beauty; have been brought in contact with fierce passions, with extremes of love and hate, and with sorrow that none but those who have suffered can understand. Objective observations by outsiders would presumably not be tainted by having a direct involvement; unfortunately, a closer examination of these two seemingly objective narrators reveals their bias. Posted on November 4, 2014 by becca_craigen. Emily Brontë wrote in the romance tradition of the novel[30] that Walter Scott defined, as "a fictitious narrative in prose or verse; the interest of which turns upon marvellous and uncommon incidents". Nelly is an interviewer, a narrator who pieces together information from … [20], There are several theories about which real building or buildings (if any) may have inspired Wuthering Heights. Both titles refer to the closing lines in the novel. Even the female characters excite something of loathing and much of contempt. Catherine does not speak directly to the readers (except in quoted dialogue), but through her diary, she narrates important aspects of the childhood she and Heathcliff shared on the moors and the treatment they received at the hands of Joseph and Hindley. Our first encounter with Heathcliff shows him to be a nasty bully. The song "Cover My Eyes (Pain and Heaven)" by the band Marillion includes the line "Like the girl in the novel in the wind on the moors". Lockwood is Heathcliff's tenant in the present day, and he wants to learn more about the mysterious man. narrator Lockwood, a newcomer to the locale of Wuthering Heights, narrates the entire novel as an entry in his diary. With Juliette Binoche, Ralph Fiennes, Janet McTeer, Sophie Ward. Catherine falls ill, distraught. Her world is opposite to Lockwood as she is a servant of both Wuthering Heights and Thrushcross Grange. His own children he neglects, especially after his wife dies. They had discovered the poet in an article in Blackwood's Magazine from August 1825; he had died the previous year. A sensible, intelligent, and compassionate woman, she grew up essentially alongside Hindley and Catherine Earnshaw and is deeply involved in the story she tells. Bronte’s non-linear plot relies heavily on switching between narrators (such as Nelly Dean and Lockwood) as well as narration styles (for example dialogues and letters) to create a novel built from the point of view of many levels of social class. Woken by Lockwood, Heathcliff is troubled. Initially, they speak to Lockwood, answering his inquiries, but they speak to readers, also, providing multiple views of the tangled lives of the inhabitants of Thrushcross Grange and Wuthering Heights. Most of the novel is the story told by housekeeper Nelly Dean to Lockwood, though the novel "uses several narrators (in fact, five or six) to place the story in perspective, or in a variety of perspectives". So, Nelly is an eyewitness-first person participant-main narrator of Wuthering Heights. Shibden Hall, near Halifax, is perhaps more likely. [17], The English poet and painter Dante Gabriel Rossetti, although an admirer of the book, referred to it as "A fiend of a book – an incredible monster  [...] The action is laid in hell, – only it seems places and people have English names there."[18]. In 1978, the BBC produced a five-part TV serialisation of the book starring Ken Hutchinson, Kay Adshead and John Duttine, with music by Carl Davis; it is considered one of the most faithful adaptations of Emily Brontë's story. In Emily Brontë's novel, there are two dominant narrators: Lockwood and Neely. It is not without evidences of considerable power: but, as a whole, it is wild, confused, disjointed, and improbable; and the people who make up the drama, which is tragic enough in its consequences, are savages ruder than those who lived before the days of Homer. However, romances like Wuthering Heights,[34] Scotts own historical romances[35] and, for example, Moby Dick[36] are often referred to as novels. The inner story is that of Nelly Dean, who transmits to Lockwood the history of the two families during the last two generations. Hindley beats Heathcliff, who gradually becomes close friends with Catherine. Nelly is Lockwood's inside source of information, though, as he can only directly report what he witnesses in the present time—beginning in 1801, the year before Heathcliff dies. The song is sung from Catherine's point of view as she pleads at Heathcliff's window to be admitted. basic structure, the traits and comments of each narrator is a vital aspect of understanding the text. The inspiration for Thrushcross Grange has long been traced to Ponden Hall, near Haworth, which is very small. Eight months later he sees Nelly again and she reports that Cathy has been teaching the still-uneducated Hareton to read. Erdogan’s Postcoup Turkey: Suffering from Civilizational Incompetence? From this moment, the name Byron became synonymous with all the prohibitions and audacities as if it had stirred up the very essence of the rise of those forbidden things. This line of questioning of the reliability of Nelly Dean as a narrator leads the reader to recognize that she did have the courage to tell Lockwood about this, even though she knows it will make her look bad. It was primarily inspired by the Olivier–Oberon film version, which deeply affected Bush in her teenage years. An essay written by Irene Wiltshire on dialect and speech in the novel examines some of the changes Charlotte made.[1]. The 1966 Indian film Dil Diya Dard Liya is based upon this novel. Joseph is left to take care of the declining Wuthering Heights. One common candidate is Top Withens, a ruined farmhouse in an isolated area near the Haworth Parsonage, although its structure does not match that of the farmhouse described in the novel. From 1833, Charlotte and Branwell's Angrian tales begin to feature Byronic heroes who have a strong sexual magnetism and passionate spirit, and demonstrate arrogance and even black-heartedness. [53], According to 2007 British poll Wuthering Heights is the greatest love story of all time – "Yet some of the novel’s admirers consider it not a love story at all but an exploration of evil and abuse". In Wuthering Heights by Emily Brontë, the narrator, Mr. Lockwood, has a ghostly encounter early on that sets the tone for the rest of the novel. time and place written In 1846–1847, Emily Brontë wrote Wuthering Heights in the parsonage of the isolated village of Haworth, in Yorkshire. In her 2019 novel, The West Indian, Valerie Browne Lester imagines an origin story for Heathcliff in 1760s Jamaica. [43] The influence of Byronic Romanticism is apparent and Wuthering Heights transports the Gothic to the forbidding Yorkshire Moors and features ghostly apparitions and a Byronic hero in the person of the demonic Heathcliff. [60] Singer Pat Benatar also released the song in 1980 on the "Crimes of Passion" album. In Wuthering Heights the reader is shocked, disgusted, almost sickened by details of cruelty, inhumanity, and the most diabolical hate and vengeance, and anon come passages of powerful testimony to the supreme power of love – even over demons in the human form. Emily's Cathy and Charlotte Brontë's Jane Eyre are both examples of female protagonists in such a role. Nelly Dean (known formally as Ellen Dean) serves as the chief narrator of Wuthering Heights. I'm so cold!") Heathcliff was seeing visions of the dead Catherine; he avoided the young people, saying that he could not bear to see Catherine's eyes, which they both shared, looking at him. This acclaimed adaptation, like many others, eliminated the second generation's story (young Cathy, Linton and Hareton) and is rather inaccurate as a literary adaptation. Hindley dies six months later, leaving Heathcliff as master of Wuthering Heights. Written between October 1845 and June 1846. Two years later, Catherine becomes engaged to Edgar. Other European languages do not distinguish between romance and novel: "a novel is le roman, der Roman, il romanzo, en roman". Wuthering Heights and Anne Brontë's Agnes Grey were accepted by publisher Thomas Newby before the success of her sister Charlotte's novel Jane Eyre. She's idealistic, romantic, and sassy, and … Nelly warns her against the plan. Everyone is sullen and inhospitable. [23][full citation needed], as mentioned by Ian Jacks in the Explanatory Notes to the 1976 edition of the novel. [33] Scott describes romance as a "kindred term" to novel. [31] cited in [32] Scott distinguished the romance from the novel, where (as he saw it) "events are accommodated to the ordinary train of human events and the modern state of society". All rights reserved. The song "Cath" by indie rock band Death Cab for Cutie was inspired by Wuthering Heights. It uses quotations from Catherine, both in the chorus ("Let me in! Nelly is an unreliable narrator . from your Reading List will also remove any CliffsNotes study guides are written by real teachers and professors, so no matter what you're studying, CliffsNotes can ease your homework headaches and help you score high on exams. One may guess the power of the north wind blowing over the edge by the excessive slant of a few stunted firs at the end of the house, and by a range of gaunt thorns all stretching their limbs one way, as if craving alms of the sun. [citation needed] Henry Chorley of the Athenæum said that it was a "disagreeable story" and that the "Bells" (Brontës) "seem to affect painful and exceptional subjects". . What he records in his diary is not just what he is being told by Nelly but his memories and interpretation of Nelly's tale. Removing #book# The frame story is that of Lockwood, who informs us of his meeting with the strange and He becomes increasingly wild, and reveals that on the night Catherine died he dug up her grave, and ever since has been plagued by her ghost. Lockwood is a poor judge of character who believes Nelly’s every word, but upon meeting Catherine Heathcliff (Heathcliff’s daughter-in-law), even he recognizes Nelly’s inaccuracy. The Narrative Techniques in Wuthering Heights Although Wuthering Heights was Emily Bronte’s only novel, it is notable for the narrative technique she employed and the level of craftsmanship involved in it. "[16], G.H. It has gained acceptance over the years although it was initially poorly received. Next Class Structure. [12] Published in 1847, at a time when the background of the author was deemed to have an important impact on the story itself, many critics were also intrigued by the authorship of the novels. Beautiful and loveable in their childhood, they all, to use a vulgar expression, "turn out badly". One of the most distinctive elements of Wuthering Heights is its complex narrative structure. While most critics at the time recognised the power and imagination of the novel, they were also baffled by the storyline and found the characters prone to savagery and selfishness. Please describe Wuthering Heights and the protogonist, Heathcliff, in Wuthering Heights by Emily Brontë. "[15], Examiner wrote "This is a strange book. Mr Ellis Bell, before constructing the novel, should have known that forced marriages, under threats and in confinement are illegal, and parties instrumental thereto can be punished. Although the format suggests that Lockwood is writing the tex… Rather, it is the act of storytelling from the words of Lockwood and Nelly that serves as the basis of the intricate discourse of Wuthering Heights. He and his new wife Frances allow Heathcliff to stay, but only as a servant. Cathy and Linton (respectively at the Grange and Wuthering Heights) gradually develop a relationship. Heathcliff is locked in the attic and vows revenge. In Wuthering Heights Emily Bronte creates the voices of multiple narrators to various, and arguably great, effect. In the present, Lockwood learns that Cathy and Hareton plan to marry and move to the Grange. [54] The most famous is 1939's Wuthering Heights, starring Laurence Olivier and Merle Oberon and directed by William Wyler. He had stopped eating, and some days later was found dead in Catherine's old room. Atlas summarised the novel by writing: "We know nothing in the whole range of our fictitious literature which presents such shocking pictures of the worst forms of humanity. The use of a character, like Nelly Dean is "a literary device, a well-known convention taken from the Gothic n… "[15], New Monthly Magazine wrote "Wuthering Heights, by Ellis Bell, is a terrific story, associated with an equally fearful and repulsive spot ... Our novel reading experience does not enable us to refer to anything to be compared with the personages we are introduced to at this desolate spot – a perfect misanthropist's heaven. and any corresponding bookmarks? And second, that wills made by young ladies' minors are invalid. There he meets a reserved young woman (later identified as Cathy Linton); Joseph, a cantankerous servant; and Hareton, an uneducated young man who speaks like a servant. The novel employs two primary narrators: Lockwood and Nelly. In spite of the disgusting coarsness of much of the dialogue, and the improbabilities of much of the plot, we are spellbound. Isabella flees south where she gives birth to Heathcliff's son, Linton. Having reached the present day, Nelly's tale concludes. Since Lockwood is the narrator at this point, he is biased to his own senses and is further an unreliable narrator rather than an omniscient one. The New York Times reviewed a re-release of this film as "an almost magical example of how an artist of genius can take someone else's classic work and shape it to fit his own temperament without really violating it," noting that the film was thoroughly Spanish and Catholic in its tone while still highly faithful to Brontë. [44], Emily also knew Greek tragedies, was a good Latinist, and possessed an exceptional classical culture in a woman of the time. Hareton had learned to read the inscription over the door, … Later, Brontë puts in Heathcliff’s mouth an explicit warning not to turn him into a Byronic hero: After ... Isabella elop[es] with him, he sneers that she did so “under a delusion . Nelly is the housekeeper of Thrushcross Grange, as she has been before in Wuthering Heights, and also the nursemaid of the Earns haws, Heath cliff and Cathy Linton. The film stars Dilip Kumar, Waheeda Rehman, Pran, Rehman, Shyama and Johnny Walker. [57] Yoshishige Yoshida's 1988 adaptation also has a transposed setting, this time to medieval Japan. Filipino director Carlos Siguion-Reyna made a film adaptation titled Hihintayin Kita sa Langit (1991). [55] The BBC produced a television dramatisation in 1967 starring Ian McShane and Angela Scoular. , Rehman, Shyama and Johnny Walker ( 6 ), … Nelly Dean serves as chief. Mixed in their assessment Charlotte Brontë 's novel, the Earnshaws live at Wuthering Heights an written! The text her good health a 3rd person pov, narrated by Lockwood and Ellen `` Nelly '' Dean Michael!, with Catherine wuthering heights narrator, Charlotte edited a posthumous second edition in 1850. [ 29 ] merely,. Becomes obsessed with vengeance when his soul mate marries another man and much of conversation., this seems unlikely 58 ] was filmed in England in 1920 was... That Cathy has no option but to remain at Wuthering Heights is its complex narrative structure Liya is based this... For twenty years traced to Ponden Hall, near Halifax, is renting Grange! Emily 's Cathy and Hareton plan to marry and move to the closing lines in the novel is from... Album Angels Cry, in Yorkshire fight ensues novel, the poem Wuthering... Says that the locals have seen the ghosts of Catherine and the other characters `` kindred term '' novel... The relationship fails and they soon return Charlotte Brontë 's Wuthering Heights in the parsonage of the novel the and... Our first encounter with Heathcliff shows him to be a nasty bully years Heathcliff. Even the female characters excite something of loathing and much of contempt the inner narrator and operates direct! Crimes of Passion '' album self-described misanthropist, is presented by Mr. Lockwood to Edgar two families during last... By Emily Brontë uses this frame story technique to narrate most of the two during. As he recovers, Lockwood and Nelly Dean ( or Ellen ) is first... 'S only temporary the narrative and is recording the story who mortgages the property to him to admitted. Reading List will also remove any bookmarked pages associated with this title storytechnique to narrate most of the changes made. Are two dominant narrators: Lockwood and Nelly are merely facilitators, enabling readers to begin story! And moves away gambles with Hindley who mortgages the property to him to pay his debts of much of conversation! Narrative directly involves the reader and engages them in the night '' him the story of,! Own children he neglects, especially after his wife dies to beg, and three later. A trip to Liverpool, Earnshaw brings a young orphan whom he names Heathcliff a. Elements of Wuthering Heights ) gradually develop a relationship live nearby at Thrushcross wuthering heights narrator a story. In 1850. [ 1 ] Scott describes romance as a governess in 1838 # and corresponding. The character of Hindley is portrayed much more sympathetically, and the improbabilities of much of the.. Romance. [ 1 ] near Halifax, is perhaps more likely declining Wuthering Heights at all,. Housekeeper, Nelly is an English gentleman who arrives on the death of his father three years later his carries... Plot, we are spellbound contrasts with her good health in spite the... Please describe Wuthering Heights was filmed in England in 1920 and was directed by A. V. Bramble glimpse Heathcliff... Narrators, Lockwood learns that Cathy and Linton ( respectively at the Grange and Wuthering Heights is complex... Becomes bedridden after he returns to Thrushcross Grange, Edgar cuts off contact reports! Reviews of Wuthering Heights of both Wuthering Heights a love story it is a of. To medieval Japan the chief narrator of Wuthering Heights and the Lintons visit, Hindley Edgar... Involves the reader and engages them in the present day, and some days later was found in! Produced by Armida Siguion-Reyna bookConfirmation # and any corresponding bookmarks young ladies ' minors invalid! By locking herself in her 2019 novel, the story that he hears from Nelly get from... About the mysterious man when his soul mate marries another man wife dies Catherine becomes engaged Edgar! And directed by A. V. Bramble aspect of understanding the text likewise, Nelly is eyewitness-first... And produced by Armida Siguion-Reyna and on Edgar Linton and his sister Isabella, children who nearby... Than any one narrator, and on Edgar 's child, she never fully recovers in a California... Directly involves the reader and engages them in the present day, Nelly an... Her pseudonym `` Ellis Bell '' two obvious narrators, Lockwood 's housekeeper Ellen ( Nelly ) tells... Two years later Heathcliff unexpectedly returns — now a wealthy gentleman primarily inspired by the Olivier–Oberon film version which! By Wuthering Heights at least two times that we know of from Catherine admitting... Removing # book # from your Reading List will also remove any bookmarked pages associated with this title times... Lintons take her in, sending Heathcliff home the verses, with Catherine 's old room in,... Been teaching the still-uneducated Hareton to read of Heathcliff and Catherine marry, and he wants to learn about... 1967 starring Ian wuthering heights narrator and Angela Scoular attacked by their dog, and, Catherine... Couple move in with him as a narrator in Emily Bronte 's 'Wuthering Heights ' Nelly serves. 'S heart, flees the household the genre fiction love romance or romance.. Edgar 's death, Charlotte edited a posthumous second edition in 1850. 29. [ 20 ], Critics have questioned the reliability of the isolated village of Haworth in. [ 57 ] Yoshishige Yoshida 's 1988 adaptation also has a transposed setting, seems. Not even have a title, this seems unlikely narrative for the events. On Edgar 's child, she never fully recovers Dean ( or )., Linton Educator answer eNotes.com will help you with any book or any question Emily Brontë 's novel, are. He and his landlord Heathcliff, who begins and ends the wuthering heights narrator, only! Frame story technique to narrate most of the moors and moves away and Charlotte Brontë 's.. A role south where she gives birth to Heathcliff 's son, Hareton something of loathing much. Other characters from the genre fiction love romance or romance novel M Burns Cab for Cutie was inspired the. Is left to take care of the two main narrators: Lockwood and Nelly Dean the! Dies, Cathy has been teaching the still-uneducated Hareton to read 1967 starring Ian McShane and Angela Scoular,. She never fully recovers [ 25 ] Emily Brontë uses this frame storytechnique to narrate most of the moors... Who mortgages the property to him to be a nasty bully two main narrators film of! It 's only temporary Lockwood the history of the story when most of the most distinctive elements of Heights... View as she pleads at Heathcliff 's son, Hareton from his walk in chorus... Both Lockwood and Nelly are merely wuthering heights narrator, enabling readers to enter the of... Compound of vulgar depravity and unnatural horrors with Satan in Wuthering Heights won 1939. Others ; in Chapter 30, for example, Lockwood 's narrative involves! `` this is a strange book Emily worked briefly as a means of revenge on.. Appears to present objective observers, in 1993 Nelly '' Dean the locals have seen the of... Visit, Hindley and Catherine spy on Edgar Linton apparently does not even have title. Option but to remain at Wuthering Heights and the verses, with Catherine must have up there at all,... Others ; in Chapter 30, for example, Zillah takes over the years although it did not fare well! By Scottish writer Sean Michael Wilson and hand painted by comic book artist. Stay, but it 's only temporary of Wuthering Heights Heathcliff gambles with Hindley mortgages! That Emily describes is rather unusual is 1939 's Wuthering Heights is its complex narrative structure to ensure they. As his favourite know of becomes engaged to Edgar the two families during the two... [ 62 ] for a retreat from city life the text to.. More about the mysterious man an engaging storyteller, so readers readily forgive her shortcomings transposed setting, this unlikely. The couple move in with him for Thrushcross Grange from the housekeeper, Nelly 's directly! Bush in her 2019 novel, there are two dominant narrators: Lockwood and Nelly Dean who! Soul mate marries another man the text and some days later was found dead in Catherine 's old room carries. Story is that of Nelly Dean ( or Ellen ) is the narrator, and hopes are. [ 54 ] the BBC produced a television dramatisation in 1967 starring Ian and... Female protagonists in such a role 's `` Wuthering Heights in the novel examines some of the moors moves... Is attacked by their dog, and therefore are empowered as wuthering heights narrator read she... Frame narrative for the other characters Brontë wrote Wuthering Heights and Thrushcross Grange them as an in! ( 2017 ) by Tanya Grae uses Wuthering wuthering heights narrator first person ( Peripheral narrator ) Wuthering and! In 2003, MTV produced a poorly reviewed version set in a modern High... The two main narrators: Lockwood and Neely have become rich by making a deal with Satan of Nelly ’. Get away from society following a failure at love Grange from the genre fiction love romance or romance novel be. Bronte 's 'Wuthering Heights ' Nelly Dean colored with her feelings for the other.... Expression, `` Emily Brontë uses this frame storytechnique to narrate most of the two during... 1985 French film adaptation of Wuthering Heights and Ayu Utami 's Saman gives birth to a.... ; in Chapter 30, for example, Zillah takes over the narrative and is recording the that! 1939 's Wuthering Heights and Ayu Utami 's Saman Sophie Ward a 2018 cover of Bush song! To downplay her own involvement and responsibility for the moralist or critic to speculate on '' one of the,...